** See below for continuing updates **
A report on the new cabinet (h/t Richard Chambers at IFES).
At approximately 8PM Beirut time, President Michel Suleiman signed the following decrees, dissolving the current cabinet and appointing the new one.
Decree #2837: The cabinet led by Prime Minister Fouad Siniora is now resigned.
Decree #2838: Saad al-Hariri is hereby appointed Prime Minister.
Decree #2839: Pursuant to the previous decree, the following are the ministers in the new Lebanese cabinet:
Saad al-Hariri (M14, Future Movement): Prime Minister
Rayya al-Haffar (M14, Future Movement): Minister of Finance
Hassan Mneimneh (M14, Future Movement): Minister of Education
Mohammed Rahhal (M14, Future Movement): Minister of Environment
Michel Pharaon (M14, Future Movement): Minister of State
Tarek Mitri (M14, Future Movement): Minister of Information
Mohammed Safadi (M14, Independent): Minister of Economy
Jean Ogassapian (M14, Future Movement): Minister of State
Akram Chouhayib (PSP): Minister of the Displaced
Ghazi al-Aridi (PSP): Minister of Public Works
Wael Abou Faour (PSP): Minister of State
Ibrahim al-Najjar (M14, Lebanese Forces): Minister of Justice
Salim Wardeh (M14, Lebanese Forces): Minister of Culture
Boutros Harb (M14, Independent): Minister of Labor
Salim al-Sayegh (M14, Kata’eb): Minister of Social Affairs
*
Ziad Baroud (President’s share): Minister of Interior
Elias al-Murr (President’s share): Minister of Defense (and vice-PM)
Mona Afeish (President’s share): Minister of State
Adnan al-Sayyed Hussein (President’s share [and Hezbollah's presumable swing vote]): Minister of State
Adnan al-Qassar (President’s share): Minister of State
*
Charbel Nahhas (Opposition, C&R): Minister of Telecommunications
Fadi Abboud (Opposition, C&R): Minister of Tourism
Ibrahim Dadayan (Opposition, C&R): Minister of Industry
Gebran Bassil (Opposition, C&R): Minister of Energy
Youssef Saade (Opposition, C&R): Minister of State
Ali al-Shami (Opposition, AMAL): Minister of Foreign Affairs
Mohammed Khalifeh (Opposition, AMAL): Minister of Health
Ali Hussein Abdallah (Opposition, AMAL): Minister of Youth & Sports
Hussein al-Haj Hassan (Opposition, Hezbollah): Minister of Agriculture
Mohammed Fneish (Opposition, Hezbollah): Minister of State for Administrative Development
**
In yet another twist to the five month-old cabinet saga, the Kata’eb Party — a key Christian ally in the March 14 alliance — has threatened to drop out of the coalition and resign from the cabinet, expressing displeasure at the ministry that it was dealt (Social Affairs). PM Saad al-Hariri has not yet issued a statement about this development, and it is unclear as to how it will impact the stability of the new government. Stay tuned…
November 9, 2009 at 3:22 pm
What’s with the four ministers of state?
November 9, 2009 at 3:35 pm
I was wondering the same thing.
What does Minister of State even mean?
Minister of Making Up Numbers? Then again, aren’t they all simply making up numbers?
November 9, 2009 at 3:53 pm
Ministers of State are “filler” ministers designed to make the sectarian math work out correctly.
According to convention, the cabinet has to be divided equally between Christians and Muslims. Also, there should be the same number of Maronite, Sunni, and Shiite seats, with the remining seats going to the smaller sects.
In order to make this work, you typically need a large number of cabinet seats, and there are only so many portfolios.
November 9, 2009 at 4:03 pm
Yep, I’m quite happy with that list. No Fatfat, no Hamedeh. Hariri did a good job. Oh my god, did i just utter those words.
November 9, 2009 at 4:04 pm
lol
Sasa, you should be happy too with the choice of the Foreign Minister:
Ali al-SHAMI
November 9, 2009 at 4:10 pm
Talal Maqdessi isn’t in it….
November 9, 2009 at 4:11 pm
Jamal! Good to have you.
I switched it; thanks for catching it. The FPMers had it wrong.
November 9, 2009 at 4:21 pm
The Kataeb are dropping out of March 14?
What a way to begin Saad al-Hariri’s cabinet…
http://www.naharnet.com/domino/tn/NewsDesk.nsf/getstory?openform&0283ED9AA3BB5DFBC2257669006DAD20
November 9, 2009 at 4:59 pm
QN,
We’ll wait and see for that one. Naharnet seems too quick with the draw lately…
November 9, 2009 at 5:52 pm
I don’t think Kataeb will drop out of M14.
What are they gonna do otherwise?
Pah-lease.
Their only other possibility is a team-up with Tayyar, at least in the Matn, if they leave M14 that is. And I don’t think that they are joining the opposition any time soon.
So, they will stay in the cabinet for now. They will bitch and moan, but will eventually come up with a statement that will have all the essential Lebanese things to put in a statement. Examples include but are not limited to: Safeguarding the constitution, preserving M14 unity, continuing on the martyr’s path, staying the course, sacrificing once more and bla bla bla.
And magically, someone’s bank account gets larger.
November 9, 2009 at 6:22 pm
I want to be a minister of state too!
What is their daily 9 to 5 like? … what do they take care of when they are not voting during government meetings?
And what can we expect from Charbel Nahhas at the ministry of Telecommunication?
November 9, 2009 at 6:25 pm
Kicking it up a notch—
Qifa — I like the quote in the New York Times!!
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/10/world/middleeast/10lebanon.html?_r=1
“When Syria and the Saudis ran Lebanon, the flexibility of the system was an asset, because it enabled them to shape political power according to their needs,” said Elias Muhanna, a political analyst and author of the influential blog Qifa Nabki. “But now that Lebanon is more in charge of its own destiny, that flexibility has become a liability.”
Elias, you have outdone yourself. Clearly Robert worth has good taste and knows worth when he hears it.
Cheers, Joshua
November 9, 2009 at 6:37 pm
An impertinent question – Is it really a wise idea to have a guy from a party of thugs and ethnic cleansers holding the Ministry of Justice seat?
November 9, 2009 at 6:38 pm
Frankly, except for the PM, if you would have shown me the lists without names, I wouldn’t be able to tell who won the elections. So why bother with them at all?
November 9, 2009 at 7:11 pm
Roger,
Your opinion aside which is totally wrong…
Please we have all heard age old tired attacks. Would you consider PSP, Amal, HA among others God sent parties with no blood on their hands?
You seem to be hung up in the past which is so endemic in Lebanese…
November 9, 2009 at 9:05 pm
Shukran Joshua!
November 9, 2009 at 9:55 pm
Oh the overwhelming anticipation, can’t wait to see them all line up for that official photo in tacky white suits.
One can’t imagine that their suits will stay white for too long!!
Pity the Nation
November 9, 2009 at 10:38 pm
Mabrook ya shabeb wya sabaya on the new cabinet formation.
Now the real work begins. Hopefully the new cabinet will work hard on dealing with the most pressing issues like the economy, energy and the environment.
Somehow, I feel a bit optimistic. Nshalla kheir.
November 10, 2009 at 2:02 am
im surprised Hizbullah didn’t take a more prominent service ministry. like ministry of health, labor, education (though, there are obvious problems with edu) or displaced…
November 10, 2009 at 2:03 am
The pros of the new Government:
- Michel Suleiman has 5 ministries.
- Mohammad Fneish is no longer Minister of Foreign Affairs.
- Kataeb might be walking out of March 14 (Sami Gemayyel is a supremacist and an alliance of only LF/FM/Independents is better off – more seats for the LF).
- Gebran Bassil got the Energy Ministry, and not that he would have been top choice, but I know he’d be willing to do anything to prove himself worthy of carrying the FPM lantern after Aoun – so serious work is expected.
- A (relatively) large number of female ministers that are not related to male politicians.
- A (relatively) large number of new faces.
The cons:
- Its formation re-enforced the consensus precedent that was established as a result of the May 7 events.
- Ministries of Energy and Telecommunications stayed with the opposition, which makes partial privatization of the sectors highly unlikely.
- Ziad Baroud and Tarek Mitri are back.
- There’s no (clear) blocking third, and if Adnan Al-Sayyed Hussein does take the oppositions side over that of the president, Michel Suleiman would feel betrayed by the opposition and see things the way they are.
-Fouad Siniora, one of the very few Lebanese to adhere to the constitution, verbatim, will be missed.
Im waiting for the Ministerial Statement to expand on those. Lets pray its as close as possible to the Priority List that QN compiled.
November 10, 2009 at 2:09 am
The PM has put togoether quite a brilliant line-up, very good reflection of voters’ choices and fair distribution of repsonsibilities between the various parties. I am happy also to see the President appoint Mona Ofeish.
The Syrian regime should be worried – when the Lebanese move forward, it shows it can be done in a multi ethnic state like Syria.
And Fatah should take note in the Land of Israel – I look forward to those people in Bethlehem and Nablus getting the right to vote for representation in the Knesset – then we will see a parliament in the Land of Israel that reflects the views of all of the subjects of the state, instead of the separate rules for separate sectarian groups as is now the case. Yallah, one person one vote in the Land of Israel in the next decade, then Syria is next after that!
November 10, 2009 at 2:11 am
NB: I know 2 women out of 30 ministers is still disgraceful, but previously, the only women we did have in the Government were sisters/widows/wives/daughters of politicians – hence it is my belief that this Cabinet carries a substantial improvement.
November 10, 2009 at 3:43 am
Hey QN,
“Adnan al-Sayyed Hussein (President’s share [and Hezbollah's presumable swing vote])”
Why?
I’d say he is no more a swing vote to the minority as Minister Elias al-Murr is a swing vote to the majority.
Unless you mean that should Amal & HA ministers resign later at some cross-road issue and Minister Hussein follows along (being the 6th Shia minister), then this could potentially bring the gov. down? If so, then no need to worry.
If you check Dr. Hussein’s biographical sketch including his long track record of teaching at the Lebanese University and at the Lebanese Army’s Command and Staff College, you would see why President Suleiman chose him (and why both sides agreed). Some of his publications could be nice additions to your Lebanon Bibliography.
Ras Beirut (18):
Likewise, I feel optimistic. Indeed, inshallah kheir.
November 10, 2009 at 5:09 am
QN,
I’d be interested to read your analysis on who you think “won” from this cabinet haggling/negotiation. Do you think by holding out so long and getting more or less what he wanted, Aoun succeeded in gaining stronger footing for himself in this government? In the end, can we say that Hariri couldn’t stand his ground and caved? If so, what does that mean for this government’s future policies and in particular for the ministerial statement? In terms of bargaining skills, it seems to me that Aoun proved his mettle, and also that Hariri’s bluff resignation didn’t really have much of an effect on reinforcing his position. Thoughts?
November 10, 2009 at 9:25 am
PN:
Yes, I meant in the event of a government resignation. That was the subtext of the 15-10-5 deal.
Blackstar,
I’m preparing a post as we speak, on the subject. Stay tuned!
PurpleMonkey:
Fneish was not Foreign Minister. Fawzi Salloukh was. Fneish was Labor, I believe.
November 10, 2009 at 1:47 pm
[...] By ethanjwagner Qifa Nabki has the breakdown of the new, and long-awaited, Lebanese Cabinet, announced last [...]
November 11, 2009 at 1:55 am
Uhhh..wow that whole post was off. Excuse me. I had just gotten a beautiful herb from the Bekaa; as you can tell, it does wonders! Hahaha
But yeah, Fawzi Salloukh as foreign minister, and the 3rd and 4th points in my cons were intended for pros.
November 15, 2009 at 5:47 am
Lebanon, Gem of The Midddle East
Lebanon will continue to be the shining star in the region, economically and politically. A stronger united and more cohesive Lebanon will soon emerge that will resist all factions being imposed in the region by sources outside of the immediate “United for Lebanon” movement. A need for intelligence gathering and containment will continue to emerge in order to plan for the greater good of Lebanon under one leadership regardless of religious beliefs.