Mustapha over at Beirut Spring alerted me to a good editorial over at NOW Lebanon this morning, which criticized Saad Hariri’s lackluster leadership and praised Najib Mikati. Because of the unusual editorial line expressed by the piece, I joked that it was only a matter of time before “NOW Lebanon” became “WAS Lebanon”.
It didn’t take look before the piece seemingly disappeared from NOW’s website. I managed to find a cached version, which I’m posting below. Maybe this was just a technical error, but if the article was in fact taken down because of pressure from Hariri, then this is a big slap in the face to many of the decent reporters who work for the site.
If the piece is posted again on the NOW website, I’ll take this post down. (I’ve added the bold-facing below.)
The Baby and the Bathwater
If we are to believe a report in al-Joumhouria newspaper on Monday, French President François Hollande and Saudi Arabian King Abdullah, in a meeting also attended by former Lebanese PM and Future Movement leader Saad Hariri, will not back current Lebanese Prime Minister Najib Miqati if a new government is formed.
Do the Lebanese not have a say in any of this? We should worry at the carefree way in which Lebanon’s future is always being decided by outside actors, no matter who they are. The region is already polarized between the Sunni and Shiite communities in a dangerous standoff between Saudi Arabia and Iran. Such horse-trading will only serve to entrench further the sense that foreign powers control Lebanon’s destiny and that each side of the political divide is justified in having its regional backer.
Another worrying aspect was the presence of Hariri, a man who must surely concede that his role in Lebanese political life must now be confined to the margins of Sunni politics. He is living in LaLa Land if he still feels that the Lebanese public would welcome him back with open arms and see him as their salvation. In fact, it would be scandalous if he stood for parliament in the next general elections, let alone offer himself as a candidate for the premiership. (Ditto Nayla Tueni and the rest of the absentee MPs who, by their negligence, have done their best to snuff out the flame that was March 14 and insult the intelligence of the voters who sent them to Najmeh Square).
For it is not enough to simply oppose March 8’s fiendish agenda and make all the right noises about democracy, independence, sovereignty and the sanctity of the state. March 14 members must also take seriously their roles as public servants. The recent deterioration of infrastructure and the apparent collapse of law and order during August have woken up the public to the fact that if they want a functioning, safe, peaceful and prosperous country, and if they want laws enacted, it will not happen if the people they elect to achieve these ends are nowhere to be seen.
Which brings us back to the issue of Miqati and his suitability for the premiership. When he accepted to lead the Hezbollah-dominated government in the spring of 2011, many saw him as an opportunist who would trade what was left of Lebanon’s integrity for a place in the history books.
In reality and with hindsight, he has not done a terrible job. He has advanced the Special Tribunal for Lebanon (despite the Syrian dream of killing the process altogether) and spoken out against Syrian violations of Lebanese territorial integrity. Given the fact that he has had to work with a cabinet of which Hezbollah and its obstructionist allies in the FPM are a part, he has made a decent fist of holding things together.
Hollande and the rest of the international community are right to condemn the current government, which has set new standards in uselessness, but we should avoid throwing the baby out with the bathwater. With the exception of former Prime Minister Fouad Siniora, Miqati is arguably the best candidate we have to lead this country in troubled times. In the meantime, the Lebanese must fight to wrestle their destiny from the hands of those who see Lebanon as a strategic asset instead of a sovereign nation, and all our MPs, without exception, should show up for work.
This isn’t the first time NOW has been critical of Hariri. They had an unashamedly mocking tone since his absence. Still, this is pretty damning.
March 14 made a mistake by targeting Miqati. They should have called for a national unity technocratic cabinet potentially led by Miqati. The current government and their foreign allies never would have supported such a move, but M14 would have gained the sympathy and support of the public.
Congrats QN you made it to Angry Asaad’s blog
Good on Now Lebanon for at least trying to say it like it is. what r the odds Al Manar, Akhbar or Safir will publish a Nasrallah critique anytime soon?
I read this too; but I thought it was a rogue piece as it was making fun of Hariri not only criticizing him. That made no sense at all. Let’s see what’s the explanation of Now Lebanon….and “with the exception of Seniora…”??? If this guy thinks that Seniora and Miqati are the salvation; he should be thrown out too!
Very big slap indeed. Thanks for reprinting it.
Miqati is hedging his bets on the results of the US elections.
If Obama wins, he will hold on to his position. If Romney wins, he will seek a quick exit.
Obviously the Gulf Royals and Hariri will be praying tomorrow morning for a Romney win.
It has been published again. It’s back online. http://www.nowlebanon.com/NewsArticleDetails.aspx?ID=454394&MID=10&PID=2
The article is now online, I have just accessed it: http://www.nowlebanon.com/NewsArticleDetails.aspx?ID=454394&MID=0&PID=0
^^^ with this “disclaimer”
“Disclaimer: NOW Lebanon has intentionally removed this article from the site. It was not removed because of censorship, but rather because of the lack of proper arguments. We would like to repeat, again, that NOW is not owned, in whole or in part, by Prime Minister Saad Hariri, nor any other political party or figure.”
kinda weak if you ask me….Mitt Romney weak